Transcript
Smiti: Welcome to Curiosity Meets the Past, a podcast for curious minds who love learning about the past. My name is Dr. Smiti Nathan, and I’m an archaeologist and your host.
In this episode, I’m speaking with landscape archaeologist, Dr. Zenobie Susanne Garrett. Recently, she launched a collaborative project with Dr. Katharina Becker and Dr. Tom Spencer called AERIAL-SCAN in order to digitize photographs from the Cambridge University Collection of Aerial Photographs (CUCAP). There are over half a million photographs in this collection, and around 13,000 a were taken in Ireland. However, most of the Irish portion has never been digitized in high resolution. AERIAL-SCAN wants to remedy that.
In this episode, Zenobie shares why preserving these photographs is important and what they can tell us about both the near and deep past.
She starts off with an example that reveals how an aerial photograph helped make a groundbreaking archaeological discovery.
Zenobie: So my favorite story about this collection actually has to do with a photo from, England. And so many, many years ago for my master’s, I did a thesis looking at the spatial organization of landscapes in Anglo-Saxon literature, so the poem “Beowulf” and in Anglo-Saxon archaeology.
I highly encourage no one to read that thesis at all. But one of the sites I looked at was a site that’s called Yeavering. And, this is a site also known as, I’m gonna say this wrong, I’m sure, Ad Gefrin, but it’s mentioned by Bede in the eighth century as a palace that was associated with King Edwin of Northumbria, And so it was known by Bede, but in the archaeological record, there was no kind of evidence for it prior to this photo, right? And so in 1948, 1949, the guy who’s responsible for the collection that we’re gonna be talking about, he flew over the site and recorded a series of crop marks, and these were recorded because it was a year of extreme drought, so they kind of popped in the, the field.
But because there was no kind of record of Anglo-Saxon halls or early medieval hall, timber halls at the time, they didn’t really know what they represented. And so an archaeologist called Brian Hope Taylor looked at these photos two years later and started to think, “Well, maybe this could be this royal palace that’s spoken of by Bede.”
And that’s what led to the eventual excavations, and it’s this huge publication.
It was transformative of our understanding of early medieval England and it’s really amazing to look at the images, ’cause if you look at the actual image of the, the photograph, it’s so clear.
Like, you look at the image and then you look at the map that was created and you can go, “Doo, doo, doo, doo, doo,” right? Like it’s, it’s not all there, but a lot of it’s there. So it’s a really, really cool instance of how dramatic these photos can be for revealing archaeology and how important this collection was for the kind of identification of archaeological sites in England and Scotland and Wales and Ireland and, like, how much of a role it plays in that.
Smiti: That’s so cool, and I’m so excited to get into this collection. And you’re specifically focusing on the Irish part of this collection. Can you give us the backstory of that and why you felt it was worth preserving?
Zenobie: Yeah. So just to kind of start with the collection as a whole, right? So the collection is half a million photographs, so it’s an incredibly large collection. It’s– It is one of the largest aerial photograph collections there is, most of those photographs are from England, Scotland, Wales, Ireland.
There’s also a bit from France and Denmark as well. And they go from the 1940s all the way up to the early 2000s. So I think the last photos in the collection are 2009. So they’re this long, intense record of landscape and change and all sorts of things, in Ireland alone, there are about 13,000 photos for the whole island, and 11,000 of those would be from the Republic, and then there’s another about maybe 2,000, maybe 2,500, I can’t remember exactly, from Northern Ireland.
Now, why is it important, So there are 2,000 sites in the National Monuments Record of Ireland that list at least one of these photographs as a source, now, that’s that we know so far. But if you do the math, if you do the spatial analysis, 76% of the photographs have a kind of geographic center within 500 meters of a site, which means that they could potentially actually record more.
And so that’s one of the things that I’ve been exploring with the collection.
And so, for example, I work near a small town or village called Kilcullen, and there’s a picture of Kilcullen as a nice town in 1962. But once you put that into a GIS and you kind of spatially align it, you can see that it actually captures another monument that was put into the Sites and Monuments Record in 2013.
So there’s a ringfort that was added in 2013, but it’s actually in this photograph from 1962, so that’s kinda cool. So there’s a lot of potential for these photos to actually capture more archeology than we know right now, so that’s really exciting. And I talk a lot about the archeology, but you know, they’re important for historical analysis, urban rural studies, ’cause you’ve got these villages, you’ve got a lot, the ’60s, and then you’ve had a lot of development.
This is kind of pre-motorway infrastructure, but this is when canals and railroads are starting to give way to cars, like people using cars more and more, so you kinda got this interesting transition in the landscape. What’s also interesting to note is that a lot of what the collection– what we know about the collection is the photographs. The photographs obviously visually compelling, visually have the information in them too, but the actual archive also has the notebooks that, were written in while, you know, flying these planes and taking the photographs, the negatives, the film, als- all sorts of kind of additional photographic history as well.
So they’re really cool. It’s, it’s just, it’s a cool, it’s a cool resource
Smiti: Yeah, absolutely. And I’m so excited to dive into the applications of these photos, especially archaeologically. But I wanna go back for a moment, and these photos were obviously taken by a person, So can you tell us a bit about the person who was taking these photographs and what aspect of their story really stuck out to you?
Zenobie: Yeah. So the whole collection was started by a guy with a very long name, longer than mine. So his name is John Kenneth Sinclair St. Joseph, so he’s kind of the impetus behind the whole existence of all this.
So he’s the one that flew many of these, flights himself. He also had a couple of assistants through the years, but he’s a fascinating guy. he’s born, I think, around 1912 or something, and he actually trained as a geologist, but he had a huge interest in Roman archaeology, so he was, like, fascinated by it, doing that, as you do on the weekends whenever you can get.
He starts this personal study of Roman roads and Roman military camps, and he starts corresponding with a guy called O.G.S. Crawford, he is a early proponent of aerial archaeology from World War I.
And it’s actually Crawford who arranges his first flight, his first aerial reconnaissance flight in 1939. So this guy goes up, and does this in, I believe it’s in Scotland. But 1939, what happens? World War II breaks out, and so, people aren’t flying planes for archaeological reconnaissance at the time, looking for Roman military, camps.
But during the war, He, he analyzes photos and it’s post-bombing campaign photos. So they’ve gone in, they’ve bombed an area, they’ve taken photographs to see the destruction, And he’s responsible for analyzing those photos, and he actually gets really good at not just analyzing them, but analyzing nighttime photos.
but he’s still very interested, in the archaeology, in the aerial potential, so once the war ends in 1945, he goes back to the University of Cambridge, but he keeps, doing aerial reconnaissance flights, and he’s actually for the first few years doing them in tandem with the RAF.
By the 1960s, the RAF is no longer involved and they buy a plane of their own, by like 1950, he already had 7,700 photographs in the collection, So very prolific worker, very prolific producer. And so he’s invited to Ireland by the National Museum.
So the National Museum invites him over to photograph certain sites, and they also tell various universities and researchers, they reach out and say, “Hey, this guy is coming over. You can submit proposals for projects.” So he comes over and he doesn’t just photograph archeology, although there’s some amazing sites he photographs.
He’s also doing geological surveys. He’s doing, village surveys for historians, all sorts of things. So it’s a really kind of diverse data set that he creates for Ireland. It’s very, very cool. And then I guess what sticks out to me about him the most is just, I think just the amount, the breadth and the scale of the work, right?
He’s not the only one that took photos, but he took a majority of these photos. It is not easy to get, universities to, buy printing paper, never mind a Cessna, so he, he just had to have been an extraordinarily, dedicated individual of this is what we’re going to do and, was able to bring people along on that journey, which has been very successful and very fortunate
Smiti: Gotcha. So that was Joseph. What about you? What made you want to take on this project?
Zenobie: well, so the reason I’m interested in this is I’m a landscape archaeologist, and I’m interested in kind of the spatial analysis of landscape. So I’m interested in how landscapes build up over time. So, you know, why do we put a solar farm here and a development here and a grocery store there?
and why does this grocery store then get torn down and turned into a gas station? That type of thing. And then I’m interested in how people organized that space and thought about it, aerial archaeology is really useful for this because you get that kind of broad bird’s eye overview, and you can see things in the landscape, and you can see relationships in the landscape.
The other thing that makes me interested in is I’m really into remote sensing techniques. So how can we discover archaeological potential, and how much can we know about the archaeology before we even dig it, Digging, finite resource, expensive, not always easy to convince people to give you money to dig square holes.
And I guess what ultimately made me take on this project, so I’ve been aware of the collection for a while, not just because of Yeavering, but also because it is a resource for many of the archaeological sites in Ireland, so I’ve checked in on it, over the years. currently on the website for the collection, there are thumbnails which are low resolution, but they’re still very useful for seeing, things.
But I’ve been thinking about, oh, it would be great if we could do some high resolution, scans and thinking about that. And one of the days I was thinking about it, I kind of went to the website to see who I might be able to contact to talk about that. And I realized that the collection was no longer open.
So the collection currently is held by the Department of Geography, and there is a very, great professor, Dr. Tom Spencer, he’s an emeritus professor, and he controls access to that collection, in the sense that he is responsible for it, but he does not have the resources to, provide digital copies or anything like that.
No one’s actually in the collection anymore. He’s just making sure that it is preserved and answering queries, via email about it. So that kinda got me starting to think about, well, okay, well, this is kind of important, Because this collection is less accessible now, and what is the future of that collection?
And so talking to Tom and then Katarina Becker at University College Cork, coming up with this idea to apply for a grant to do a trial run at digitizing some of these, So We applied for a grant from the Royal Irish Academy.
And, what’s really nice about it is it supports digitization. So there’s a lot of grants that will not support digitization only, even though that’s an important aspect. So this does that, and it allows us to digitize about 1,500 images. We picked four counties in Ireland, to digitize. They’re Kildare, County Laois, County Louth, County Dublin, and that’s gonna be our first set of images that we’ve scanned for the Irish collection.
And so this is kind of our first foray into doing that, and the hope is this will make the case for, this collection’s very important.
We really need to like digitize it, preserve it, and like make this collection more accessible ’cause it’s a very easy collection for people to be interested in. people are interested in photographs. People are interested in what it looks like where they currently live, what it used to look like, you know, places they’ve been. And they did a pilot at Cambridge, where they digitized 1,500 of the English photos, and they said the response was incredible.
And so, what we can do to draw attention to the importance of the Irish part of this record and digitize it would be great.
Smiti: Oh, I’m so excited to see what the response is gonna be. And I’m wondering, like you talked a little bit about landscape changes before and how powerful these images are in surfacing that.
Is there a particular archaeological story about landscape changes that this collection highlighted that really stuck with you?
Zenobie: So I myself am still kind of exploring the richness of this collection. I mean, I knew the importance of the sites that I was interested in, but now I have, much more to look at. And so there’s not a particular story, but there’s certain examples that I think really stick out. So one, just looking at these small villages and the amount of transformation they’ve gone through.
You have the main street, you have the houses, you have the shops, and then you can see this kind of huge explosion if you compare them to the modern satellite images of housing and development and how they’ve spread. So another one that I think is really interesting I was looking through the photographs and there’s one on the, I wanna say it’s on the Dublin-Meath border and there’s this huge, site in the photograph. It’s about 200 meters by 100 meters. It’s banked, kind of earth. It’s square, it’s rectangle, it’s massive.
It is not there anymore. So the photo was taken, I think in ’69. It was bulldozed sometimes in the ’70s. It is recorded by the Monuments Record, so it is known, but if you look at satellite images from dry years in like you can see a little bit of the foundation for it, but we have a photograph of what it looked like.
it takes on that sense of how important this is for recording monuments because the landscape has changed so much. And then the other thing I love, so there are several kind of big sites in Ireland that are excavated during the time that he’s here. So, the sites of Knowth, the site of Newgrange, Navan Fort, And so he actually has taken photographs during these excavations. So one of the things that we’ve added to our remit is, we have about, I wanna say 30 photos from the excavation of Knowth. So you can go through the photographs each year and see where they were excavating and it’s this kind of incredible record, not of the archaeology, but of the process of creating the archaeology record
Smiti: oh, absolutely.
I think your stories and insights have highlighted just how rich this collection is. And, as we were speaking, I realized, this collection is connected to World War II, and to me, that both highlights and alludes to the connections between politics and archaeology.
I’m curious, how do you see that connection?
Zenobie: Well, so there’s been a long examination, and critique of that kind of relationship, so archaeology as a way to challenge political ideology, but also we have plenty of evidence of archaeology being used to promote political i- ideologies, but also even, as a cover for political activity, So, in the case of political conflicts, so war, you have archaeologists who have used products from that, like satellite imagery, maps, those types of things, to record monuments and to record destruction and to, maintain an archaeological record that’s at threat.
But also, it’s helped to find new sites, And so an example of that would be the declassified Corona imagery, from the United States, So you have these amazing records of particular areas of the world, that were in really high definition and great detail for the ’60s because we wanted to know what was going on there.
And once they were declassified, archaeologists have been able to d- to use those, they were declassified in the ’90s, to, look for archaeological change, archaeological destruction, archaeological sites. And so that’s been, a great project that has come out of that. But the reason I was talking about, I said political conflict, archaeologists have used products.
I think it’s really important to not say benefited from, Because we don’t wanna say that conflict has benefited science, because in reality, think of what could have happened, if we weren’t spending the money on political conflict and we weren’t creating conflict in the world. You could have way better research in the arts and sciences, So it’s not a benefit, but it is a product that we have tried to repurpose and use for, a different, hopefully better outcome. and I think with this collection in particular, because I’m very interested in the preservation and digitization of it, I think if we look at politics and archaeology now, so if we look at it in the States, for example, now, there’s been a lot of discourse around what is being erased, What is being taken away, what is being deleted, what web pages are going away, what is not being funded. And so I think In that sense, it kind of brings up the power of redundancy, of having digital copies, of having physical copies, of having them in different places. So with our project, they’re gonna be held on the Cambridge Digital Library website, and they’re also gonna be held in the Digital Repository of Ireland, so they’re in two different kind of digital places.
And so, the importance of redundancy and preservation, I think is actually important. I think everybody thinks we’ll just digitize it, and then we can throw away the paper, and that’s not really, a great idea. We want to preserve what we can because we know things won’t last forever.
And so if we try to preserve what we can, maybe something will make it, so I think the collection, It comes ultimately out of St. Joseph’s interest in aerial archeology for archeological prospection, but it is tied to the use of aerial reconnaissance in World War II, I think we just have to really think critically about what gets funded, what gets recorded, and why. And so I think it just shows that our knowledge of the past has its own history,
Smiti: I really appreciate the nuance and care you took in answering that question and providing kind of the ethical context of what we consider as we look at different artifacts and their contexts, and also thinking about actions we can take in the present. So what has working on this project meant to you personally?
Zenobie: It’s no secret from our discussion, I love this collection. I’m very fond of it. I just think it’s incredible, and I want everybody to not necessarily feel the same way, but get the chance to feel the same way by having access to it too. So I really like this project. It brings together a lot of my skills, So I trained in archeology, I trained in remote sensing, I trained in spatial analysis. Since grad school, I’ve never held an archeology job. Now, I’ve still done archeology, and I’ve gotten to do a lot of incredible things. I’ve still been in academic, arenas, and so, you know, I’ve gotten to do all sorts of other things like 3D object, uh, research and, geography and history.
So I’m not complaining about it at all, but it’s very exciting to get to use my, highly specialized and very limited archeological skills on this kind of project. So I’m very, very excited about that. And it gives me a chance to explore other research options within the collection.
So it’s really made me more of an advocate for it. Like, “Listen, sit down, I’ll buy you a cup of coffee, and then listen to me for 30 minutes about why this is important,” because it just, it is.
Smiti: As a friend, it’s been really cool to see you light up as you talk about this collection and your work on it, and I would love to hear what you hope listeners take away from our conversation today.
Zenobie: I guess there’s a couple things. So I want listeners, despite me just saying it, to kind of hopefully have understood how unique and how unparalleled this collection is in some ways, not just because of the archeology, although that’s what I’ve talked about. You can see changes in kind of field definitions and the aggregation of smaller fields into larger fields, or the reuse of fields for development, So urban studies, you have geology, you have infrastructure, so you have railroads, you have canals, you have roads being built or going into disuse.
So you have, you have all sorts of interesting data in this collection. It’s not just about the archeology, although please, the archeology is super important and I love it. But you know, this collection is amazing for a variety of different kind of fields and questions.
The other thing I think I would want people to take away from it is that there is an ongoing value to old photographs. I think a lot of times, especially in an era, you have high-resolution satellite imagery on your phone, and it can kind of be like, “Well, we have better images now. Why do we need this kind of old static small image?”
But these photos still have incredible value because we don’t have satellite imagery of this resolution from this time period, for Ireland.
It captures a unique time. It captures details that we might not, have now, but it also because of, the climatic conditions it was taken in, the lighting conditions all these types of things allow certain features to exist in these photographs that might not even exist in satellite photos today.
So I know that there’s images of crop marks from areas around where I’ve worked that I’ve looked at the satellite images from the driest years in the past, you know, 10 years, and they aren’t there. Now, I don’t know what that means. It could mean that, those images might not be archaeological, or it could just mean that there’s something with the kind of the land use today that makes them, not visible.
We don’t know. But it’s recorded somewhere in that photograph, and that old photograph is still important and saying things that despite all our great, technological advances, are not being said today. So yeah, so how unique it is, the ongoing value of old photographs, old things are important.
And I guess, just how foundational this collection is for archaeology in these areas, and therefore, the importance of preserving it.
One of my biggest takeaways from this conversation is that some of the most important collections containing information about the past already exist. We just need to make the effort to not only explore them, but preserve them for future generations.
If you’d like to follow the AERIAL-SCAN project, you can check out their Instagram, BlueSky, and Facebook. And if you’d like to keep up with what Zenobie’s doing, you can follow her on LinkedIn.
You’ll find those links in the show notes along with link to the full transcript of this episode.
And if you’re curious to dig deeper and learn about Zenobie’s postdoc journey, she shares that — and more — in a Patreon-exclusive video.
Our Patreon is completely free to join and gives you access to all of our bonus content. If you’d like to support the podcast monetarily, we’d of course appreciate that, too. Thanks so much for listening and cultivating your curiosity with us. We’ll see you soon.
Credits
Zenobie Susanne Garrett: Guest
Noor Hanania: Theme Music Creator
Laura Riveiro: Podcast Cover Art Creator
Brooke Norton: Production Support
Smiti Nathan: Host, Video Editor
Patreon Supporters
Thank you to our paid Patreon members for supporting the creation of this episode:
Nancy Fulton, Giancarlo Annese, Thomas Martin, Stuart A. Griffin, Tagg, Ann Brookens, Diana Madden, Cole Guinn, GeometryGirl, John McGrath, Cris Nally, Mick Bradley
YouTube
Spotify
Pocket Casts
Amazon Music
iHeart
Overcast
Goodpods
More Options
Instagram
Patreon
Leave a Reply